Get a free, no-obligation rental analysis today.
Overview
Let us manage your New Tampa Rental Property
Owning a residential rental property can be a lucrative investment, but can also come with headaches and worries. With PMI Arrico Realty & Property Management, we will help you save time, money and hopefully reduce your Stress!
The Power Is in the Process.
PMI Arrico Realty & Property Management follows proven processes throughout the rental cycle, maximizing everything from marketing the property, screening tenant applications, executing lease monitoring compliance, tenant relations, coordinating/overseeing maintenance and finally, finalizing the lease termination and security deposit disposition within the legal timeframes. And if there’s any maintenance required, we’ve got you covered there too! We have licensed and insured vendors that we have worked with for years, even on our personal homes, that will take most anything from installing an elevated AC Filter to building, renovating or just refreshing the home for maximum wow factor to increase the appeal and hopefully the rent. Trust the power of the process and enjoy the peace of mind a good property manager provides.
- Ready
- Select
- Protect
- Renew
Get In Touch With Us
Fill out the form below and we will be in touch. Want immediate help? Call us at 813.662.9363 .
Step 1: Ready
With over $5 billion of assets under management, PMI is the expert in residential property management. During the Ready process, we thoroughly analyze and inspect your property, making recommendations and repairs for ideal marketability. From there, we gather professional property photos, display the needed signage, and engage the use of lock boxes to maximize showings. Once that is set up, we advertise on the PMI Syndicated Network, both locally and nationally.
Property Walkthrough
- Professional-quality photography
- Detailed property description intake
- Secure property access
Exclusive PMI Listing Network
- Live listings on dozens of credible websites
- Personalized and enticing listings
- Broad and effective advertising
Maximize Your Revenue
- Thorough assessment and pricing based on sophisticated data
- Property improvement recommendations to increase profitability
- Exceptional maintenance and protection plan for the property
Step 2: Select
Once the property is ready, we Select a qualified tenant following Fair Housing law to lease your property. We start this step with a professional showing system that includes self-showing and 24/7 online access backed by a driver’s license and credit card requirement. Applicants will then go through our advanced screening process, which uses industry-best technology to screen each applicant properly. At PMI, we never lose sight of getting the lease signed and the property occupied.
Showings
- Professional showing system
- In-person or self-showings for pre-screened prospective residents
- Safe and reliable walkthroughs
Screenings and Approvals
- Advanced tenant screening to minimize risk while maximizing occupancy and rental revenue
- Approvals comply with fair housing, credit reporting, and privacy requirements
Lease Signing
- Electronic leasing process for faster lease signings and tenant move-ins
Benefits
- Faster property occupancy
- Reduced risk of identification scams
- Placement of highest qualified tenants
Step 3: Protect
PMI will Protect your investment into the future by managing your property through industry-leading accounting, maintenance, and communication. We ensure on-time rent collection and promise to manage a property as if it’s our own. Property owners can rest assured knowing they will get their funds by the 10th working day of each month. They also receive expense reports and a monthly accounting statement, along with tax statements. If there’s any maintenance required, we’ve got you covered there too! We have licensed and insured vendors that we have worked with for years, even on our personal homes, that will take most anything from installing an elevated AC Filter to building, renovating or just refreshing the home for maximum wow factor to increase the appeal and hopefully the rent. Trust the power of the process and enjoy the peace of mind a good property manager provides
Manage Lease Terms
- On-time rent collection
- Properties managed like they’re our own
- Tenant compliance support
Accounting
- Fast delivery of owner funds
- Copies of all expense receipts
- Accurate real-time statements
- End-of-year statement and 1099 tax reporting
Property Maintenance
- Pre-tenant move-in review
- Annual or semi-annual property review
- Final walkthrough
Step 4: Renew
The result of Ready, Select, Protect is a quality tenant who will Renew their lease and enhance the return on your investment. The renewal process starts 90 days in advance. We analyze the tenant’s payment performance, assess the property’s condition and conduct a market analysis (for any updates on the rental price).
Results and Improvements Review
- 60-day advanced renewal process
- Tenant payment performance analysis
- Property reviews assessment
- Comparable-based market analysis
New Lease and New Tenant Support
- Advanced marketing
- Inspect, repair and refresh the home for maximum wow factor to increase the appeal and hopefully the rent
Are You Maximizing the Return on Your Rental Investment?
Enter your info and receive a free report about your property and neighborhood!
Receive Your Free Report
Shortly after submitting your information, you’ll receive a personalized property analysis report evaluating your home with a suggested rent range and market data.
Expert Evaluation
The property’s location, condition, and amenities will determine the actual rental value of your home. To get the most accurate value possible, please speak with one of our market analysis experts.
As Your New Tampa Property Manager, We Do More Than Find Great Tenants.
Property Marketing
We work to quickly find the right tenant for your property and use our proven marketing methods to attract high-quality applicants.
Learn MoreTenant Screening
Every application undergoes careful screening, with background and financial checks designed to keep your interests protected.
Learn MoreRent Collection
Getting your rent payment on time shouldn’t be a guessing game. We handle all billing, and work to get your money to you on time.
Learn MoreProperty Maintenance
We know how to keep your property in optimal condition. We handle all maintenance requests and coordinate needed repairs for you.
Learn MoreAccounting and Financial Reporting
PMI provides accurate worry-free accounting to owners with monthly reports and any-time access to our reporting dashboard.
Learn MoreEvictions
If a tenant relationship ever takes a turn for the worse, we can process the eviction for you and minimize its impact on your bottom line.
Learn MoreProperty Inspections
Our regular in-person inspections allow us to identify potential problems in advance and keep your home healthy.
Learn MoreLegal Compliance
We monitor the laws and insurance regulations that impact your property and work to ensure that your property is legally compliant.
Learn MoreHome Watch
For owners of second homes who want the security of knowing their property is being watched and cared for while they are away.
Learn MoreHow much rent can you get for your investment? Find out now!
free rental analysisRest Easy Knowing Your Rental Is Protected.
21-Day
We guarantee to find a quality tenant for your rental property in less than 21 days, or we will waive the first month of management fees!
Learn MoreEviction
If a screened tenant placed by PMI Arrico Realty and Property Management ever has to be evicted, we handle the eviction process, including the costs or fees associated with eviction, up to $2,000.
Learn MoreOn-Time Rent
When a tenant pays rent on time, we promise to have your owner’s payment in your account within ten business days. If not, we will give you back that month’s management fee.
Learn MoreHappiness
If, for any reason, you are not completely happy with our services and want to leave us, you may cancel your property management agreement without penalty with 30 days notice.
Learn MoreResults
We don’t get paid until you get paid. With PMI Arrico Realty and Property Management, you will have peace of mind, knowing that we are working hard for you, and you will not need to pay us until you get results.
Learn MoreLeasing
You should never have to pay twice for us to find a new tenant for your property. Our leasing guarantee states that we will find a new tenant for free if a tenant does not fulfill at least nine months of a lease term.
Learn More
We believe in the best customer experience possible and guarantee our results! Let us show you the difference PMI Arrico Realty and Property Management can make. Schedule A Consult
Investing In New Tampa Rental Properties
New Tampa, a master-planned community in the northern part of Tampa, Florida, is quickly becoming a sought-after destination for real estate investors. With its blend of suburban comfort, modern amenities, and steady population growth, New Tampa offers excellent opportunities for investors looking for reliable cash flow and long-term property appreciation.
With its family-friendly vibe, strong rental demand, and proximity to major employment centers, New Tampa stands out as a high-potential market in the Greater Tampa Bay Area.
Market Growth Highlights
- Rapid Residential Growth: New Tampa has seen steady growth as families and professionals seek more space and quality neighborhoods. Its population has increased consistently year over year, reflecting demand for housing in this expanding suburb.
- Proximity to Employment Hubs: Located just minutes from the University of South Florida, AdventHealth Tampa, and Tampa’s business districts, New Tampa offers residents a short commute to major employers in education, healthcare, and tech.
- Affordable Investment Entry: As of mid-2025, median home prices in New Tampa hover around $395,000—offering a competitive entry point compared to Tampa’s core, while providing larger properties and modern communities.
- Strong Rental Market: Rental demand remains high, driven by professionals, families, and students. Local property managers report average occupancy rates above 92%, with annual rent increases of 3–5% projected through 2026.
- Investor-Friendly Environment: Florida's tax structure—no state income tax—and pro-landlord laws continue to attract real estate investors to the area.
What Makes New Tampa Unique?
- Outdoor Lifestyle: Miles of trails, golf courses, and parks such as Flatwoods Park and the New Tampa Nature Park make it a haven for outdoor lovers.
- Modern Community Amenities: Gated communities, top-rated schools, and upscale shopping at The Shops at Wiregrass cater to families and professionals alike.
- Convenient Location: Easy access to I-75 and Bruce B. Downs Boulevard connects residents to downtown Tampa, Wesley Chapel, and the Gulf beaches.
- Education & Healthcare: Near USF, Moffitt Cancer Center, and Florida Hospital, making it ideal for healthcare workers and students.
- Safe and Family-Friendly: Known for its low crime rates and suburban charm, New Tampa appeals to long-term renters seeking security and quality of life.
Your Partner for Property Management in New Tampa, FL
Investing in rental properties in New Tampa is a smart move—and partnering with a trusted property management team is the key to maximizing returns. Whether you're looking for New Tampa rental property management, investment guidance, or reliable tenant placement, we deliver full-service solutions tailored to your investment goals.
From tenant screening and leasing to rent collection and maintenance, our experienced New Tampa property management professionals handle it all—so you can focus on growing your portfolio with confidence.

Areas We Serve
Don’t see your neighborhood? These are just a few cities and communities we offer management services to. Contact us if you don’t see yours; we are always looking to expand!